The Log Home Inspector


Inspected Once, Inspected Right!
   

Kent Shepard
1750 30th St.
Boulder, CO 80301
USA
(303) 258-8289
(303) 717-8940


  • Home
  • EXPERT WITNESS
  • LOG HOME INSPECTION
  • NEW CLIENTS
  • INSPECTIONS
    • My books
    • Your Report
    • Contact me
    • Resistograph
    • TECHNICAL PAGES
      • PROF. RESOURCES
      • GREEN BUILDING
        • LOG HOME INFO
        • Fire PerformanceFire Performance

          © 2008, Kenton Shepard

          The construction of log homes in the U.S. has grown by approximately 45% since the mid 1980’s. The enactment of codes requiring smoke detectors in homes has helped tremendously in limiting injuries, fatalities and property damage and loss.

          Most log homes are built in rural areas served by volunteer fire departments. Although fire alarms are helpful, the amount of damage to the home depends upon the response time of the local fire department.

          Inspectors will sometimes be asked how well a log home will perform in a fire and this section will help provide answers.

          HOW a HOME BURNS

          Fire goes through 5 different stages in the process of burning a home to the ground.

          I. The first stage after ignition is called “pyrolysis”. This is low, slow, flameless smoldering in which the fire may not have enough oxygen to accelerate. Pyrolysis may last minutes, hours or days. From the early stages of pyrolysis, the fire moves into a smoldering stage in which smoke develops, a flame may appear and ambient temperatures increase.

          II. With the development of flames, temperatures may rise to 1000°F. within 5 minutes.

          III. In as little as 5 minutes after reaching 1000°F, the confined, hot expanding combustible gases may explode in a process called “flashover”.

          IV. After only ten minutes, it’s possible for a home to be “fully developed”; a condition which can last for hours.

          V. After being extinguished, the burned material goes into a cool-down period which can last for hours or days, depending on the amount of burned material and how it’s handled.

           

          IGNITION

          In considering how well a log home might perform during a fire, let’s look at ignition.

          The fuel load of a fire is the total amount of available fuel. This consists of- in addition to everything combustible in and on the home- the logs.

          The fuel array describes the size of fuel particles and their arrangement. Generally, small particles ignite much more easily than large particles. Logs are obviously very large particles and therefore are relatively difficult to ignite.

           

          RATE of BURN

          The safety requirements with which newer home must comply are listed in the International Residential Code (IRC), which uses ASTM E-84 as the standard for evaluating flame-spread characteristics.

           

          FLAME SPREAD AND SMOKE DENSITY (per section R-319)

          Wall and ceiling finishes shall have a flame-spread classification of not greater than 200 and a smoke-developed index not greater than 450 according to ASTM E-84 testing.

          The ratings are grouped into three classes:

          Class A: has a flame-spread of 0 to 25 and are usually specified for escape routes in buildings with large occupancy expectations.

          Class B: Ratings of 25 to 75 apply to rooms over 1500 square feet in area and ascape routes in buildings with moderate occupancy expectations.

          Class C: Ratings of 75 to 200 apply elsewhere in areas of low to moderate fire hazard conditions.

          Based on ASTM E-84 testing, classifications of softwoods commonly used in log home construction range from 60 to over 150.

          The following table shows the results for various wood species commonly used in log home construction:

          ASTM E-84 Flame-spread Table for 19mm solid lumber as reported in the literature.

          WOOD SPECIES (a)

          Flame-spread Index

          Smoke Developed Index

          Source

          Bald Cypress

          145-150

          -

          CWC

          Douglas Fir

          70-100

          -

          UL

          Engelmann Spruce

          55

          -

          HPVA2

          Western Hemlock

          60-75

          -

          UL

          Pine, Eastern White & Northern White

          120-215

          122

          CWC, UL

          Lodgepole Pine

          93

          210

          CWC

          Ponderosa Pine

          105-230 (b)

          -

          UL

          Red Pine

          142

          229

          CWC

          Southern Pine

          130-195

           

          UL

          Redwood

          70

           

          UL

          Western Larch

          45

          -

          HPVA2

          Western Red Cedar

          70

          213

          HPVA

          Oak (Red & White)

          100

          100

          UL

          Walnut

          130-140

           

          UL

           

          CWC- Canadian Wood Council

          HPVA- Hardwood Plywood and Veneer Association, 1997

          HPVA2- Hardwood Plywood and Veneer Association, 2000

          UL- Underwriter’s Laboratory

          (a) Due to wide variation in the species of the pine family and some confusion due to common (local) names, exact identification of the types of pine tested was not possible. The effects of differing climate and soil conditions on the burning characteristics of given species have not been determined.

          (b) In 18 tests of Ponderosa Pine, 3 had values over 200 and the average value of the rest was 154.

           

          FIRE PROTECTION MEASURES

           

          SMOKE DETECTORS

          The enactment of codes requiring installation of smoke detectors has resulted tremendous improvement in fire safety, but whithin the past 10 years injuries and deaths have increased in hme in which smoke detectors wee installed but were inoperable.

          Smoke detector placement may vary with local jurisdictions, but in general, they should be placed to protect sleeping areas. It’s a good idea for inspectors to know local requirements and include in the Inspection Report narratives which mention smoke detector placement and maintenance, especially if detectors are battery-operated instead of hardwired.

          • The fire death rate in homes with working smoke alarms is 51% less than the rate for homes without this protection.
          • 65% of reported home fire deaths in 2000-2004 resulted from fires in homes with no smoke alarms or no working smoke alarms.
          • Why do smoke alarms fail? Most often because of missing, disconnected or dead batteries. Nuisance activations were the leading cause of disabled smoke alarms.

                                                                                                   –National Fire Protection Association

          FIRE MITIGATION

          In addition to smoke detectors, inspectors should understand what is appropriate for their area in recommending fire mitigation such as creating zones of defensible space.

          Defensible space is an area around a structure within which fuels and vegetation are treated, cleared or reduced to slow the spread of wildfire towards the structure. It also reduces the chance of a structure fire moving from the building to the surrounding forest.

          The following recommendations are from the Colorado State Forest Service Guidelines:  
            
          Zone 1 is the area of maximum modification and treatment. It consists of an area of 15 feet around the structure in which all flammable vegetation is removed. This 15 feet is measured from the outside edge of the home’s eaves and any attached structures, such as decks.
          Zone 2 is an area of fuel reduction. It is a transitional area between Zones 1 and 3. The size of Zone 2 depends on the slope of the ground where the structure is built. Typically, the defensible space should extend at least 75 to 125 feet from the structure. Within zone 2, the continuity and arrangement of vegetation is modified. Remove stressed, diseased, dead or dying trees and shrubs. Thin and prune the remaining larger trees and shrubs.
          Zone 3 is an area of traditional forest management and is of no particular size. It extends from the edge of your defensible space to your property boundaries.
          Inspectors should take the time to find out what fire mitigation programs are recommended for the areas in which they operate by visiting The National Database Of State And Local Wildfire Hazard Mitigation Programs.

          FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS

          In log homes built on homesites remote enough that response times for the local fire department are bound to be long, inspectors might consider the inclusion of a report narrative which mentions the advantages of installing a fire suppression system.

          A fire suppression system is one which applies a smothering, non-combustible substance (water, foam, dirt, etc.) which isolates fuel from the oxygen required for continued combustion.

          In areas where wildfires are a significant hazard, fire-proof roof coverings and sprinkler systems which protect combustible roof covering materials are common options.

          WATER for FIGHTING FIRES

          In fighting a rural fire, the fire department needs more water volume than can be supplied by connecting to the home water supply through an exterior faucet. If a home has no fire hydrant or stream nearby, the fire department will typically depend upon water supplied by fire department tanker trucks which can carry up to 15,000 gallons on board.

          At about 7 lb. per gallon, water is heavy (15,000 gallons weighs about 50 tons), and the trucks required to haul water are heavy. Roads, bridges and driveways which provide the approach to a home will need to be constructed and maintained in a manner which will allow fire department pumper and tanker trucks to use them.

          CISTERNS

          Inspectors can recommend that their client consider the installation of a cistern, which is an underground tank, but cisterns are often ineffective for the following reasons. 

          Connection Times

          Upon arrival at a structure fire, if everything goes right, the time required for a pumper truck to connect to the cistern, prime the pump and begin putting water on a fire can easily be 10 to 15 minutes.   

          Proximity to the Home

          Depending on the homesite, locating the cistern far enough from the home to allow truck to approach it may be difficult. If a cistern is located in front of a home it won’t be used because firefighters don’t park their equipment in front of burning buildings.

          Capacity

          Minimum cistern tank sizes as established by local jurisdictions are not always rooted in reality. It’s not unusual for a minimum tank size to be 500 gallons. Modern fire trucks pump water at a rate of about 300 gallons per minute (GPM), which provides 1½ minutes of water for a home using a tank meeting the minimum requirements. 1½ minutes of pumping may extinguish a car fire, but unless it’s in the very early stages…not a structure fire.

          To provide about 30 minutes of pumping at 300 GPM,  a 10,000 gallon cistern would need to be installed at a safe distance from the home.

          The Urban Wildland Interface Code stipulations for water supply are as follows:

          • 1 or 2-family dwellings not exceeding 3600 square feet must provide water supply capable of providing 1000 GPM for a minimum of 30 minutes.
          • 1 or 2-family dwellings of 3600 square feet or greater must provide water supply capable of providing 1500 GPM for a minimum of 30 minutes.

          Exception: A reduction in required flow rate of 50%, as approved by the code official, is allowed when the building is provided with an approved automatic sprinkler system. 

          FIRE-RELATED CODES and REGULATIONS

          The Urban Wildland Interface Code MENTIONED ABOVE was developed and made available by the International Code Commission (ICC) starting in 2003. This code is in use in certain jurisdictions only and inspectors making comments about fire-safety requirements should take steps to determine what fire-related codes or regulations apply to the area in which the subject property is located.

          THERMAL DEGRADATION OF WOOD

          Exposure of wood to fire causes thermal degradation or pyrolysis of the wood in which wood is converted to char residue and volatile gases. The amount of damage depends on both the temperature and the duration of the exposure.

          Below 212° F- for a short exposure, the mechanical effects are reversible.

          Above 150° F- Prolonged exposure can result in permanent strength loss.

          Under 392° F-  Charring requires prolonged exposure.

          392° F to 572° F- Significant degradation occurs.

          550° F to 842° F- vigorous flames

          FIRE-DAMAGED WOOD

          As wood burns, there’s a steep temperature gradient across the outer layers of wood, with the hottest part at the log outer surface and the coolest part toward the interior of the log.

          A “steep temperature gradient” means that although the surface of the log may be very hot, temperatures only a short distance into the log into the log will be much cooler.

          The gradient might look something like this…

          550° F - Temperature at the log surface.

          350° F –  ¼-inch deep into the log.

          220° F –  ½-inch deep into the log.

          The char rate for logs is approximately 1½ inches per hour when exposed to the standard ASTME 119 (ASTM International 2007) fire exposure, which involves specific durations at specific temperatures.

          Char rates will vary with wood species, density, moisture content and duration of exposure.

          LOAD CAPACITIES OF DAMAGED LOGS

          As mentioned, logs contain a steep thermal gradient, and the loss of strength in logs is related to the duration of exposure to temperatures high enough to cause strength loss.

          This means that strength loss only occurs to portions of the log a short distance inward from the char layer. A thick log may experience a significant amount of heat and charring at its exterior surface and still retain significant or full strength in a large portion of its remaining wood.

          If only the outer layers of wood in a log have gotten hot enough to lose strength, the inner portions will still have significant load-carrying capacity.

           
          Sources for More Information 

          This publication offers an excellent section on fire assessment and should be read by inspectors who perform log home inspections.

           

          For more details or to schedule an inspection, Contact the Log Home Inspector!

           

                            

           

           

             
           

          Home Inspection Web Site design and hosting by Grassfrog Technologies. Copyright © 2005-08, all rights reserved.